Electric collars are one of the most helpful, yet misunderstood dog training tools out there. They are also the most overused tool out there in my opinion. Electric collars should never be the starting point for a dog’s training journey, but rather a destination if necessary. Electric collars occupy both ends of the spectrum; a lot of people hate them, and a lot of people love them.
This is not going to be an article about the ethics of using e-collars. In my training, I do use e-collars in very specific applications. There are lots of trainers using them inappropriately, and lots of trainers using them in humane ways and getting fantastic results. There will always be people that would use any tool possible to hurt a dog, but that says more about the person than the tool.
When are e-collars necessary?
In my opinion, e-collars are the most overused tool in the dog world. There are too many trainers that exclusively train every dog they come across with the aid of an e-collar. There is no nuance, there is no problem solving, just straight to the e-collar. For me personally, a situation has to tick specific boxes before we discuss using the e-collar.
These are the 2 main reasons for using the e-collar in my training; off leash training, and a bark collar for very specific situations. I don’t use the e-collar for countersurfing, jumping on people, barking at dogs on walks, etc. Those problems can all be trained away without needing to resort to a (at least) $200 tool.
Off leash training starts with teaching the dog all the obedience they will need without the e-collar. Everything is taught with food, toys, leashes, and collars. Once the dog has a solid understanding of the obedience, as well as good behavior inside the home, I will begin to use the e-collar to reinforce what the dog already knows.
Bark collars should also be used sparingly (in my opinion) for the average pet dog. If the barking is intense, and the owners live in an apartment or townhome and are facing eviction or fines because of the barking, then we have that conversation. Even then, the goal is to use it during training, and wean it away so they don’t rely on a bark collar for the rest of the dog’s life.
Before You Say Yes to the E-Collar
When you worry more about what tools you will use, instead of how we can fix the problems, nuance goes out the window. Be wary of who you let train your dog. If they recommend an electric collar right off the bat, ask them why the dog can’t be trained without it. Even if your dog is “aggressive” (a completely different can of worms you can read about here), you should be asking that question.
There is no agency that regulates dog training. Anybody can buy an e-collar on amazon and call themselves a trainer. They will meet limited success of course, but that doesn’t stop people from trying.
The e-collar is a fantastic tool for dog training when the situation warrants utilizing it. But you should have a nuanced conversation with your training about why they feel the e-collar (or any tool for that matter) is necessary.
Ready to Start Training?
Check out Scarlet K9’s training options and get in contact with us today to start a training plan!
