Skip to content

Why is my dog so fearful and nervous?

Puppy eyes

We have recently been working with a lot of dogs that suffer from high levels of anxiety and nervousness. Dogs that walk around and are afraid of most things, including people and other dogs. Most of these dogs are rescue dogs so we have no way of knowing what happened to them in their past. But, there are a couple ways we can deduce why they are so afraid.

Genetics

Genetics predetermine many facets of your dog’s personality and temperament. Genetics are so much more than just the breed of your dog. It’s a roll of the dice. The better the parents, the better roll of the dice you get, in general terms. 

What do I mean by “the better the parents?”

Calm, stable, confident dogs will generally give way to the predisposition of their puppies to be calm, stable, and confident dogs. If the two parents are well behaved, medically sound, and don’t suffer from nerve issues (anxiety, fearfulness), they boast a higher chance of giving birth to puppies that have predispositions to be the same way.

Parents that are erratic in nature, suffer from medical conditions, and suffer from nerve issues boast a higher chance of giving birth to puppies that have predispositions to be the same way. 

When we purchase a dog from a rescue/shelter, we are not in control of this factor. We get what we get and we take a risk. That risk can lead to the best dog in the world, or it can lead to significant problems. Is there anything wrong with purchasing from a shelter/rescue? No, not at all. Scarlet is from a rescue and now she’s the poster child for a dog training company. However, you need to be realistic as to what you are possibly getting. 

Upbringing

The other large aspect that plays into your dog’s temperament and personality is their upbringing as a puppy. Specifically, we are talking about the critical period of socialization. The critical period of socialization plays (wait for it…!) a critical role in determining your dog’s world view. 

The critical period of socialization takes place between 8 weeks and about 4 months of age. This is the time that puppies generalize from their experiences.

  • I meet a couple dogs, all dogs are cool
  • I meet a couple people, all people are cool
  • I go to a couple places with you, I’m cool wherever we go

If your puppy had good/neutral experiences during this time, chances are almost 100% that they aren’t afraid of most things they experience. Puppies that experienced positive/neutral interactions during this period are usually stable (not fearful) and confident in adulthood. 

Puppies that were neglected or had negative experiences during this period generally grow up with significant behavioral problems. Fear, anxiety, and aggression generally stem from this time in a dog’s life. 

Most dogs have a mix of positive, neutral, and negative experiences during the critical period of socialization, which means they don’t turn out overly confident, or overly fearful of anything. 

Dogs bred by the Amish for example, tend to grow up with significant behavioral and emotional issues. The vast majority of dogs we see from the Amish have significant issues with fear and anxiety, which can often turn into aggression. Backyard breeders tend to be the same way.

Whenever caution is thrown to the wind in order to seek profit, you usually get bad breedings and bad upbringings. 

If you are looking for a purebred dog, this is why you seek out a reputable and ethical breeder. You should not be cost cutting and shopping for a cheap dog, because that’s when you find backyard breeders interested in profit over furthering the proper standards of a breed. 

In conclusion, genetics and upbringing are the cause of most major fear related issues in adult dogs. Doing your research and finding the right breeder/rescue to purchase your dog from can save you a dog’s lifetime of difficulty.

Let's Talk!

Learn more about our training programs! Interested in training? Fill out the contact form and we will contact you as soon as we can. Make sure to include information about your dog’s age, breed, current behaviors, and overall training goals.